A Trader Girl's Guide To The Universe

I admit it – I’m jealous.

Right now, I want to be American.  I want to buy cheap houses and eat mega-huge fast food.

But most of all, I want a stock market that goes up.

Ours appears to have forgotten how.   In fact it’s almost as though it’s pulled the doona* over its head and decided never to get up again.

If you ask me, that’s kind of bizarre because you’d think the Australian Market has everything to live for.

You see, economically we rock.  We have stable banks, interest rates that actually pay money and a resource sector that has the rest of the world drooling.  And we have jobs for anyone who actually wants to work.

Now compare that to our American friends.  Their banks have a less than sterling reputation, interest rates can barely go any lower, and there’s very few jobs in many areas – in fact whole towns are dying through the extinction of industry.

And yet their market is merrily making higher highs without a care in the world, while ours is languishing like a drunk on Sunday morning.

The Aussie market, circa 2007.

*”doona” is Australian for a feather-filled quilt that you have on your bed.

So What Gives?

It simple really – the economy does not equal the stock market.

What does equal the stock market is people’s perception of what might happen in the future, and this goes some way toward explaining what’s going on with the US market.

Even though right now their economy is junk, people are overjoyed that there are green shoots appearing.  People are more optimistic about the future.  It doesn’t matter that right now, things are still rubbish – the fact is there is hope.

If the markets were a reflection of the economy, the US market may have risen marginally to reflect the odd green shoot.  But what’s happened is not marginal, it’s a beautiful big fat money-making up-trend.

On the other hand, the Aussie economy is solid and people are happy about that – in a very unexcited manner.  We’d actually be much happier if things had been dismal and there had been some kind of catalyst to make us think our future is brighter and things are on the up.

Sadly, while things are going well, us Aussies need more drama. We’re sick of ‘solid’.  We expect solid, and solid is priced in.

This puts us in a slightly scary place, because if things suddenly don’t seem so solid – due to China shutting up shop, for example – things could drop like a stone as we saw in August last year.

We need news that China is going to be building 20 new cities in the next two years.  That might spur things along a little.

One of China's 20 New Cities. Please?

It’s All About Expectations

The Stock Market is not a snapshot of the economy.  It’s a snapshot of people’s expectations and fears.  It’s a snapshot of their hope, or the absence of hope.

Make sure you don’t get confused, or suddenly you’ll find yourself long ‘solid and unexciting’, and short “optimism and hope” – and that would be a shame.

Wouldn’t it, everyone who’s been watching this spectacular rally from the sidelines? 😉

***

Liked it?  Please subscribe over there (up a bit…up a bit.. Got it!) ->>

And follow me on Twitter, or Facebook.

Hated it?  Why not tell the world?  The share buttons are right below.

Comments on: "Why I Want to be American" (16)

  1. The only thing the stock market is a snapshot of is timed, calculated computer programs. The human element is reduced to herds following these programs, nothing more.

  2. shortbustrader said:

    probably is better to not use the word “doona” on a blog post.

  3. You need a central banker who loves to “QE” your market upward every time it drops 2%. Problem solved.

  4. […] The economy is not the stock market: the case of Australia.  (RogueTraderette) […]

  5. […] Aussie Trader, Jessica Peletier, succinctly points out the disconnect often seen between an economy and its stock market: I admit it – I’m jealous. […]

  6. stroppythewonderdog said:

    Don’t worry, the human capacity for irrationality is boundless.

    This current sensible Aussie attitude of saving and not over-paying for anything (unless you are a miner trying to employ someone), yes, this too will pass.

    In one direction or the other.

  7. Nicolas Granja said:

    Hi Jessica,

    I am new to your blog, so this is the first article I read. I had a look at your other articles and it seems to me that you are a technical trader (as opposed to fundamentalist) and that you trade many different things. It strikes me as weird that you care about what happens in the American Stock Market, the fact that there has been a strong 3 month rally really means nothing, it is just a bunch of stocks in one country. I agree with you that with flat markets in the last year it has been difficult to trade in general, but with a good system you should get ahead in the long run: with a rally, a crash or whatever in between.

    In any case, congratulations, you have a really nice blog.

    • Hi Nicolas, nice to meet you 🙂

      I suppose you could ignore the US market, but it’s the biggest market in the world, and our often follows in it’s footsteps so it can pay to keep your finger on the pulse 🙂

      It also gives another trading option when our market is hideous, like it has been for the last couple of years!

  8. Greg Cunningham said:

    I tend to think of it as, rather than “how we feel about the future of the market” but instead “how we feel about the future of the market right now” which in a sense is blinded by temporary states of affairs… state of… current stuff.

    No market goes up forever though. We might be near a top. Hope not, but there is always a top and a bottom. Waiting years would suck bad though. And I’ve never heard of a doona. 🙂

  9. I have no idea what your market looks like but it sounds like you just described the Canadian market. And I have no idea why anyone would want to buy anything on this market right now. My theory is there is a lack of players and the market is overrun by algos that keep reloading the sell side. Catch 22 as the more they do it, the more they discourage people from trading this market, hence the continuing declining volume.

  10. Phillip Connolly said:

    Hello Jesssica, Here’s my take on the US market from the perspective of another huge pink coloured country on the globe – Canada. like Australia,we Canadians have decent banks, are resource rich, and are somewhat conservative when it comes to fiscal matters – though since the bust of 2008, many Canadians have been gorging themselves on cheap debt and it may not end well, but I digress. What cannot be underestimated when it comes to anything the Americans do is their systemic fortitude. For years, the french attempted to build the Panama canal, it ended before they ever really got started – they were terrible at it. The Americans came in and turned it into a Henry Ford industrial mega project and sliced a path through the continents. So what does this have to do with a rising US stock market? Basically the Americans will just keep pushing no matter what. Two crazy assed, ill fated wars? check. Maintain and increase social services while at the same time cutting taxes to the detriment of the national debt? check. Rally up the stock market while all evidence clearly shows some caution is in order? check. You see, our ever swaggering neighbors to the south just believe it will work and will continue to see the glass half full – even though said glass is cracked, leaking, and in need of a good wash. While I would never bet against them, (individually Americans are a wonderful people) I would also not want to be one since (collectively they are just this side of bonkers) their attitudes are not generally based on reality. That said, I trade almost exclusively in American equities. Go big or go home.

    • I’d love to trade US equities, but the market opens at 11pm our time and I’m not that committed 🙂 There is a lot to be said for just pushing on, I must admit – and thankfully the charts will tell us when those cracks aren’t holding together anymore. Thanks for posting!

  11. […] I read an article in an Australia traders blog http://roguetraderette.com/2012/03/20/why-the-economy-does-not-equal-the-stockmarket/ titled ‘Why I want to be American’ and how the underperformance in the Australian […]

Don't be shy - tell me your thoughts!